Lake House

The Lake House has gorgeous views, is historic, and reminds me of an old-fashioned, rustic lodge. I imagine people going there as kids and bringing their kids back to share the experience and enjoy the water. I enjoyed a lovely dinner with a view of the lake. Once I got back from my trip, however, I noticed I was charged for that dinner twice - once, before tip - and again, with my generous tip. After exchanging multiple texts, I was assured they'd "look into it" and credit me for the pre-tip dinner, but nothing happened. That, unfortunately, left a bad taste in my mouth.

We could not stay there. There were animals there, and it did not smell good. The rooms were not near each other, and it was not clean. I have asked for a refund. Please contact me to finalize this.

The Lakeview Hotel was very charming. The bed was very comfortable. I was in town for a concert which I parlayed with the Baseball Hall Of Fame. Getting a ride was rather trying but the staff came through for me.

We stayed 2 nights in July as a pit stop to Cooperstown. The owners Chris and Gene are wonderful. They are warm and attentive and make you feel at home. You feel like a part of their history while you are there. But Don’t expect a regular hotel, it’s more like an old bed and breakfast house experience. Complete with creaky floors and clutter. We were in a 3 room, 2 bed cabin by the water rather than in the main building, so our experience was somewhat different. It was an experience more like camping, than like a regular hotel room. The floor was warped, due to the building’s age. The rooms were tight, but beds were comfortable, and a decent sized bathroom with a basic prefab shower. There was a small window air conditioner which was strong enough to cool the room perfectly. I loved the unique experience, but my wife was not as enthusiastic. She’s paranoid when it comes to bugs, and was worried we might have a multi legged guest during the night. But it did not happen. We had to brush out some dead flies when we arrived, but that was expected due to the cabin’s location to the lake. I do not know what the rooms in the main house were like, so I can’t compare. I think next time we would stay there. I recommend eating at the on-site restaurant. You don’t have to travel to town, great staff, and the food is very good. And you can’t beat having dinner while watching the sun set over the lake! Overall, I would recommend the Lake House Hotel.

Save yourself, this place is dirty, small, and has bugs crawling around in the bathroom! The beds were uncomfortable, and the pillows and sheets seemed like they were bought 30 year's ago. We paid for a cramped room at an extremely high rate. If I hadn't paid for a non-refundable room we would of gone somewhere else completely.

I was a bit nervous after seeing some bad reviews. Our room was clean. It looked just like the pictures. When you first come in it is not like a typical hotel, it is more like a camp. You are on a lake so a tiny bit musty smelling just as you come in but the rooms are not like that at all. Many books and games to use during your stay. Common areas on each floor with a full kitchen and dining space and porches on the 3rd floor. No elevators so look for a 1st floor room if that is an issue. The staff was very helpful and friendly. The restaurant has limited hours but the food was great. Hot coffee in the morning but no breakfast. Some diners up the street close by though, Cassidy’s was very good. This is not a fancy area. If that is what you are looking for go to Cooperstown. This is quiet, affordable and quaint. 20 minute drive to Cooperstown and Milford.

This is a very cute place to stay on the lake. It is a very old hotel but was clean. Our room was small but that was ok. The floor, due to the buildings age, had a very bad slant. The old bed cover needs to be replaced. We did not eat there so we have no comment on service. We did not have any interaction with staff or other guests.

Not many places like this left in America. Not a Thruway Hotel, but rather a classic, rustic inn. Fun for that reason (and there was a band playing on the patio that night). Thin walls, you can hear the next room.