We stayed at The Witchery to celebrate our 20th anniversary and were really looking forward to the experience, both at the hotel and the restaurant. Unfortunately, it fell well short of expectations. Upon arrival, we felt more like a nuisance than welcomed guests. We dropped off our bags and returned later when our room was ready, only to be greeted by a concierge who seemed not to recognize us from earlier (it's an 8 room hotel). Not exactly the warm welcome you hope for, especially for a special occasion. The room itself was unique and eclectic. We appreciated the character and atmosphere, but unfortunately, the rest of the experience didn't live up to the setting. We expected the restaurant to be a highlight, but the service was slow, the dishes were rather bland, and the beef was disappointingly chewy. Later that night, our sleep was interrupted around 3 a.m. by noisy neighboring guests. The only highlights were the night porter, who brought us breakfast early and helped with our luggage, he was a very kind gentlemen, as well as our driver that The Witchery helped arrange to the airport. We understand the charm and appeal of The Witchery, but charm alone doesn't justify the price. For what we paid, we expected exceptional hospitality, a memorable dining experience, and a comfortable night's sleep. Unfortunately, we didn't feel we received any of those. For comparison, we also stayed at The Balmoral during our trip, and it was far and away a better experience and well worth the value. The overall hospitality and experience made it clear what a difference thoughtful service can make. We've reached out to The Witchery twice since our stay to share our concerns and express our disappointment, but have yet to receive a response. That lack of follow-up has only added to our frustration. We were excited to celebrate such a special milestone here, which makes the disappointment even greater. Ultimately, The Witchery felt more focused on its reputation and atmosphere than on delivering the experience its prices promise. We left wishing we'd spent that money elsewhere.